I recently deleted Private Practice from our list of DVR season passes. The final straw for me was the last episode, in which Addison, whose job it is to take care of patients, and whose practice is suffering from a lack of said patients, drops a patient because she is a call girl. Addison seems to think it is her job to judge her patients rather than to provide them with medical care. And not only to judge, but to deprive those deemed immoral of needed care. Sure, there are other fictional doctors that the fictional call girl can visit. But if a real doctor did what Addison did, it would pretty much ensure that the call girl would never again be honest with her doctors, which would certainly affect doctors' ability to assess her needs. And we, the viewer, were supposed to applaud Addison for taking this firm moral stance.
This may have been the last straw, but it was not the only straw. The show is not great. Really, it is not even good. I watched it anyway. I think this particular episode just struck a chord in me and reminded me that, as a society, we actually seem to be going backwards in terms of women's sexual and reproductive freedom, and the repression and condemnation of women's sexuality. It fanned the flames of the anger I have at the Bush administration for trying to enact last minute rule changes that will allow pharmacists, doctors, and nurses to deny women things like birth control, the morning after pill, and abortions, all legal, due to "provider conscience." (I don't know if they have actually finalized this. If so, it was within the last week and I was busy with days and days of snow, and yuletide joy and whatnot.) It is not the medical community's job to judge the morality of my actions while deciding on my medical treatment. If I want contraceptives so that I don't wind up with a family of 12, and birth control is perfectly legal, the pharmacist should do his job and give me the damn pill. If he doesn't believe in birth control, he doesn't have to use it. Just like Addison doesn't have to be a call girl. I'm not questioning that decision in the slightest. Well-paid, comely surgeon is definitely better than call girl. But telling your patient, "No pap smear for you, you dirty whore!" seems counterproductive, and an abdication of professional responsibility.
So long, Addison McJudgey Montgomery. I will not miss you. I will, however, miss Judging Amy and Taye Diggs' abs.

